Rehearsal Dinner

The Lightner Museum

Wedding Day

Ceremony

Reception

Our Wedding

Carli and Ben’s story is one of timing and persistence. Carli and Ben grew up in the same town and attended the same high school. Ben played basketball with Carli’s older brother and Carli played volleyball with Ben’s younger sister. They knew who each other were, but never knew each other. Some years later, Ben asked Carli on a date. Upon receiving a reluctant “yes” from her, he left her alone until the date, which was months later, in order to not ruin it. Over the next four years, life took them down different paths. Carli became an attorney in Tennessee, and Ben became a pilot in the Air Force in Texas. Even still, they never could leave each other alone. After many Nashville and Del Rio trips, and a large move to the Texas border town for Carli, Ben asked her to be his wife on the bank of Lake Amistad in Del Rio. Her “yes” that time was anything but reluctant.

Our Story

Photos

Michael Steinbacher

Rylie Newell

Remi Tuttle

Cheyenne Galasso 

Rebekah Bollinger

Brooke Bollinger

Karleigh Schuhlen 

Nicole Parks 

Samantha McCaleb

Keriss Bliss

Barrett Bollinger

Ethan Steinbacher 

Nash Fiedler

Rylee Tuttle

Colton Tuttle

Caden Tuttle

Wedding Party

Nights of Lights

Please book your accommodations early! It is Nights of Lights in Saint Augustine during this time of year which means the city will be lit up but busier than normal and rooms will fill up quickly!

Airports

If you are flying in, check out the Saint Augustine Airport, Jacksonville Airport or Orlando Airport to see which one is best for you!

Accommodation Options

Below are just a few of our favorite options! However, there are so many more Hotels, Airbnbs and VRBO's to choose from!

A local favorite! Located across the street from The Lightner, this hotel offers a luxurious experience in the heart of downtown, Saint Augustine!

Casa Monica Resort & Spa, Autograph Collection

Located across the street from The Lightner, this adult-only inn offers a unique and intimate lodging experience. Perfect for those looking to immerse themselves in the charm and history of the city!

The Collector Luxury Inn & Gardens

This hotel is a short drive to the venue and is a great option if you are looking to stay just outside the historic district! Room Block Information:You can book through the link below or by calling&nbsp;1.800.HILTONS&nbsp;and giving the reservationist their code:&nbsp;90-H ﻿hilton.com/en/book/reservation/deeplink/?ctyhocn=USTSSHW&amp;groupCode=CHW90H&amp;arrivaldate=2026-12-11&amp;departuredate=2026-12-13&amp;cid=OM,WW,HILTONLINK,EN,DirectLink&amp;fromId=HILTONLINKDIRECT

Homewood Suites by Hilton St Augustine San Sebastian

Located across the street from The Lightner, this inn is a great option for a romantic getaway! This unique building dates to 1873.

Old City House Inn & Restaurant

The Bayfront Marin House offers a variety of options - from cozy bed and breakfast rooms right on the water to private cottages and suites throughout Saint Augustine. A great choice to suit all of your needs!

Bayfront Marin House

Located on the bayfront of downtown, Saint Augustine and is a great option for those who want to stay in the heart of the downtown area.

Best Western Historic Bayfront

For our guests that want to stay on the beach, The Embassy Suites is a wonderful option!

Carli & Benjamin

Carli & Benjamin

Wedding Party